Document Type
Student Research Paper
Date of Creation
Summer 2026
Department 1
GLI History
Abstract
In 1810, the Ohio Valley Waⁿdát (Wyandotte) leader Šaʔteyarǫnyes (Leatherlips) was executed by five Wyandotte kinsmen on a charge of witchcraft. More than 200 years later, the political context of his death sentence remains obscure. Generations of white settler authors have chronicled Leatherlips’s death story. Each version of his story employs literary tropes like “the Noble Savage” and “the Vanishing Indian” to communicate a sense of the inevitability of the dispossession of Indigenous peoples from the land now constituting the state of Ohio in the federal republic of the United States. In doing so, they have concealed his political and diplomatic agency to serve their rhetorical purposes. Previous studies have failed to closely interrogate settler versions of the execution story for their social, political, and economic context. The failure to do so thus has contributed to the erasure of Native sovereignty in the region from local and Native memory. This paper uses political documents such as United States War Department correspondence, government treaties, and communications with sovereign Native nations, as well as the published histories of his death to show that the repetition and evolution of the story has contributed to Ohioans’ belief that their state had been a terra nullius before the takeover of the United States. Americans’ sense of the Ohio Country as existing in a state of nature or as virgin soil has subsequently underpinned the growth of the political and commercial economy of the white settler state of Ohio.
Creative Commons License

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 License.
Recommended Citation
Speicher, Ellen, "“You Are Not So Well Acquainted With Us As We Are With Ourselves”: Settler Mythmaking of the Leatherlips Execution Narrative" (2026). GLI MA in American History Student Works. 18.
https://cupola.gettysburg.edu/glihist/18

Comments
Written for AMHI 699: Capstone in American History.