To Have Done With the Death of Philosophy: Derrida’s Theory and Practice Seminar

Roles

Student Author: Ryder Hobbs '25

Document Type

Article

Publication Date

6-21-2023

Department 1

Interdisciplinary Studies

Department 2

Philosophy

Abstract

In this essay, we read Derrida’s Theory and Practice seminar against the backdrop of the theme of the “death of philosophy,” prominent in 1960s French philosophy. This theme takes two forms—one Nietzschean-Heideggerian and the other Hegelian-Marxian. We summarize both before turning to Derrida’s treatment of Althusser’s views on the Hegelian-Marxian form of this death. Althusser posits a distinction between theory in the general sense and Theory as a designation for Marxist dialectical materialism. Derrida gives two specific criticisms of Althusser that we discuss: (1) Althusser commits himself to a tautology, by arguing that Theory only makes explicit what is implicit already in Marxist practice; (2) Althusser ultimately establishes the priority of practice over theory. We refute both of these charges before concluding that, prior to the distinction between theory and practice, is the world itself; and presenting itself to us as unthinkable, the world places the demands upon us that it be engaged with, in theory and in practice.

DOI

10.5840/symposium20232713

Required Publisher's Statement

This article is available from the publisher's website.

This item is not available in The Cupola.

Share

COinS